Prospectus (September 1999)
`The Future is Not What
it Used To Be' (grafito on a wall in Buenos Aires).
How true this is for labour
internationalism! Organised labour has been profoundly disoriented by the
new world disorder of globalisation, neo-liberalism and informatisation.
The familiar markers of industry,
employment, class, community, ethnicity, gender, nation, state, culture,
ideology, party and strategy are in movement, or have been removed. And
it would seem that the old trade union and socialist internationalisms,
based on strong national organisations of labour, no longer meet the challenges
posed.
Yet, whilst some radical
left social theoreticians think that labour as an emancipatory movement
is as dead as the dodo, stirrings and upheavals, here, there and everywhere,
suggest that, whilst it has been profoundly disoriented, labour is now
getting up from its knees, defending itself, asserting itself, even attacking
and, above all, seeking to reinvent the internationalism that it itself
once invented.
This resurgence of labour
internationalism takes many shapes, sizes and forms but its practices echo
the agenda of those that emerged on the fringes, or at the base, of organised
international unionism in the late 1960s and 1970s. These international
labour pioneers established local, national and international labour resource
centres and publications to provide services for workers at community and
enterprise level, and for national movements peripheralised by the state-and-bloc
internationals of the period following World War II. Inspired by the spirit
of 1968, these centres were open to feminist, ecological and human-rights
activism, as well as being anti-capitalist and anti-imperialist.
Today, many of the major
organs of international labour are beginning to use the ideas, language
and strategies pioneered by these labour solidarity activists over the
past 30 years.
This regeneration of labour
internationalism has attracted the attention of a new generation of committed
thinkers deploying new types of scholarship. Labour internationalism is
looked at not only in terms of political economy or industrial and international
relations, but also in terms of social movement theory and in relationship
to global civil society projects. Feminists in the field consider (and
further) internationalism for and between the growing number of women workers
- and working women. Notions of labour-community alliances, or the alliance
of labour with the new radical-democratic social movements, are being projected
onto the world stage. A notable and novel contribution is that of radical
social geographers, focusing on labour in place and space. Labour is also
being examined as it expresses itself in cyberspace, making a contribution
to a global culture of solidarity and sustainability.
This special issue of Antipode:
A Radical Journal of Geography may well be the first academic journal devoted
to this subject. It will consist of a number of articles and an introductory
review essay which outlines current developments and debates.
The issue will be published
in late 2000 or early 2001 and the first deadline for submissions is March
31, 2000. We welcome all contributions, but especially those from younger
scholars and activists, and those covering areas and arguments that are
customarily marginalised in academic publications. Depending on the quality
of the special issue and the interest it generates, we will consider later
republication in edited book form.
Please contact the editors
for further information, and we ask that all potential contributors contact
the editors to discuss their proposals before they begin. Please pass on
this proposal to all those with an interest in labour internationalisms
today.
Peter Waterman (p_waterman@hotmail.com)
Jane Wills (j.wills@qmw.ac.uk)
Possible Contributors,
Contributions, Abstracts, Etc. (January 2000)
1. Author and address
Compa, Lance
Professor of Labour Law
Cornell University
7717 Garland Ave
Takoma Park
MD 20912
USA
Tel: +1-301-270-0161
Email: lac24@cornell.edu
compal@hrw.org
2. Subject or title
The North American Agreement
on Labor Cooperation and International Labor Solidarity
3. Abstract or description
(Extract from draft)
A five-year review of experience
under the NAALC is just a first chapter in what will surely be a lengthy
saga recounting the promotion of workers' rights in connection with expanded
trade. The story will not be one of straight-line advances, either. The
forces arrayed against workers' interests are powerful and do not easily
yield to trade union demands for greater voice in trade and investment
matters. Looming negotiations on a Free Trade Agreement of the Americas
(FTAA) raise the stakes for a labor rights-trade linkage. In the FTAA context,
the experience and the views of labor movements in Mercosur countries (Brazil
most significantly) and other hemispheric bodies will be important. The
NAALC by itself will not be the only example of workers and their allies
grappling with the effects of global trade and investment on their unions
and their wages and working conditions. But is an example that provides
valuable experience and insights into fashioning a strong social charter
to advance workers' rights in the 21st century.
1. Author and address
Dave, Alana
International Federation
of Workers' Education Associations
GMB College
Manchester
UK
2. Subject or title
Workers' Education And Labour
Internationalism: International Study Circles
3. Abstract or description
1. Author and address
Grenier, Guillermo and Bruce
Nissen
Florida International University
2. Subject or title
Unions and Mass Immigration
3. Abstract or description
Part of the internationalist
consciousness of union leaders and members concerns how they relate to
foreign born workers within their own borders. To the degree that
immigrants are viewed as anything other than welcome members of the union’s
membership, nationalism will be playing a part preventing unions from operating
in a manner needed in today’s world. One of the most neglected issues
in the discussion of ‘globalization’ is that of immigration. To a
very large degree, the recent mass immigration to the United States from
poorer countries of the world is an integral part of the internationalization
of economies, both in the United States and in other countries. The
world-wide neo-liberal agenda has uprooted traditional economies and removed
many protected industries and jobs from lesser developed countries. Mass
impoverishment and the moving of economic opportunities across borders
has driven millions of people to migrate, either legally or illegally,
to advanced industrial countries like the United States. While the U.S.
labor movement has been fixated on trade policy and the loss of domestic
jobs, it must also pay attention to the other side of the same coin: mass
immigration, especially from underdeveloped areas of the world. Our paper
will focus on the alternative responses to mass immigration that U.S. unions
have pursued. Case studies of south Florida unions will be developed.
South Florida is a good choice for examination because it has experienced
intense immigration and therefore illustrates the types of changes and
pressures that will be facing other areas of the U.S. in coming decades.
Reasons for differing reactions of unions will be sought within the structural
and attitudinal factors of each union. Factors such as union structure
(craft vs. industrial), degree of change in composition of the workforce
in the particular industry, presence of a substantial number of the immigrant
‘ethnic stock’ already in the pre-existing workforce, presence or absence
of any union leadership of first or second generation immigrants, and the
‘subjective factor’ of the ideological attitudes of local and national
union leadership will be examined. Present union practices will be evaluated
in terms of success in integrating new immigrant members into their ranks.
The most successful seem to be led by politically progressive leaders who
consciously strive to include and elevate the immigrant membership to leadership
positions. Environments where the workforce ‘mix’ is either heavily
immigrant or else has a longer history of the immigrant ‘ethnic stock’
within its membership make progressive attitudes more likely, as does an
industrial union structure. We conclude with recommendations for
‘best practice’ of union leadership from a progressive left perspective.
1. Author and address
Herod, Andrew
Department of Georgraphy
Georgia University
Athens
GA
USA)
2. Subject or title
Organizing Globally,
Organizing Locally:
Geographic Scale and Union
Spatial Strategy
3. Abstract or description
Globalization has unleashed
a powerful set of economic, social, political, and cultural forces and
processes with which unions must deal. To date, much writing on how unions
must adapt to the new realities of the global economy has suggested that
they will have to operate transnationally if they are to be successful
in the next century. Thus, international labor solidarity has been argued
by many to be the essential strategy for unions to pursue. It is by matching
the global organization of their employers, so this argument goes, that
unions will be most successful. However, a number of recent campaigns (such
as the 1998 GM-UAW strike in North America) suggest that local organization
can also be highly effective in combatting a transnationally organized
corporation, particularly if such local disputes target crucial parts of
that corporation’s organization. Thus, for example, in the case of the
GM-UAW dispute the strike of some 3,000 workers at one metal stamping plant
in Flint, Michigan effectively brought GM’s North American production to
a halt, led to the laying off of over 200,000 workers, and had impacts
on plants as far away as Singapore. Unions, then, may be faced with a choice
-shaped for sure by the contingencies of their particular situation- between
confronting economic globalization through international actions aimed
to link different workers in different locales across the planet together,
or by engaging in well-articulated, very local campaigns against particular
key "control points" in a corporation’s structure. In this paper I argue
that each of these strategies incorporates within it different conceptions
of geographic space. The first assumes that global economic space has essentially
been "flattened out" with transnational corporations capable of locating
virtually anywhere. Differences between places are assumed to have become
so minimal that a corporation has freedom to choose to locate in any one
of a myriad of possible locations, each much the same as any other. In
such a conception, unions must operate globally so as to conquor global
space and match the global geographic reach of their employers. Such a
strategy represents a "global-down" strategy. The second assumes that even
in a hyper-mobile global economy, particular places are still important
for corporations because of their skill mix, their location in certain
national or regional markets, and the like. The need for corporations to
engage in such "strategic localization" (ie to locate operations in particular
places) means that unions may effectively disrupt the operations of a corporation
through activities focused on only a small number of strategically located
operations. In such cases, disruption of operations at one or two key facilities
will have ripple effects that drag into a dispute other plants. Such a
strategy may be said to represent a "local-up" strategy. In drawing this
distinction I do not mean to prioritize either strategy as being somehow
naturally more useful for workers. Rather, my goal is to suggest two things.
First, which ever of these spatial strategies is most successful will depend
upon the contingent relations within which workers find themselves in different
places. Second, by understanding how what I call the "politics of geographic
scale" (ie which strategy is likely to be most successful, a global campaign
or a local one) play out, it is possible to see how places in different
parts of the world may be linked together through labor union campaigns
against particular corporations, whether these are globally-oriented or
locally-oriented campaigns.
1. Author and address
Hyman, Richard
Warwick University
Coventry CV4 7AL
UK
Tel: +44-203-523-840
Email: irobrh@rapier.wbs.warwick.ac.uk
2. Subject or title
European Industrial Relations:
From Regulation to Deregulation to Re-Regulation?
The End of An Old Regime
and the Struggle for a New Order
3. Abstract or description
How far is ‘Europe’ an arena
in which trade unions can effectively coordinate their actions to respond
to the dynamics of a capitalism which has increasingly escaped the constraints
of national regulation? How far are ‘the cultural values of human experience’
a resource which unions can adopt, and adapt, to win a popular legitimacy
which in most countries they have manifestly lost? And how far can this
provide a basis for a different style of European engagement, one which
might allow the European trade union movement to re-invent itself as an
effective protagonist of a genuine ‘people’s Europe’?
1. Author and address
Jakobsen, Kjeld Aagard
Secretary of International
Relations
Central única de
Trabalhadores
Rua Caetano Pinto 575
CEP 03041-000
Sao Paulo
Brazil
Tel: +55-11-242-9411
Fax: +55-1-242-9610
Email: kjeld@cut.org.br
2. Subject or title
New Challenges in the Inter-American
Regional Workers Confederation (ORIT)
3. Abstract or description
(extract from a review article
by Peter Waterman)
The Inter-American Regional
Organisation of Workers, universally known by its Spanish initials as the
ORIT, was, during the Cold War, a byword for US corruption, covert operations,
the splitting and domination of Third World unions. The AFL-CIO used it
at will, conjointly or alternatively to the ICFTU itself and its very own,
but state-funded and CIA-linked, American Institute for Free Labour Development.
Perhaps it is a combination of the hyper-irrelevance of the ORIT, the savage
effects of neo-liberalism on labour in the sub-continent, and the failure
of the Eurocentric ICFTU to respond with speed and relevance to globalisation,
that has led to the ORIT playing something of a vanguard role with respect
to both the continent and the ICFTU. It would have been nice if this new
internationalism had reached the ORIT from the shopfloor. But given the
past dependence on nation states, national parties and nationalist ideologies,
any mass internationalism amongst Latin American workers has been the exception.
The ORIT has been not only democratising itself internally and reaching
out to unions regardless of political or international affiliation. It
has also been playing an active role in various cross-sector, cross-border
civil society alliances attempting to confront the wave of inter-state
free-trade initiatives in the Americas. This, inevitably, means entering
non-union networks, alliances and coalitions - to the silent chagrin, here,
of the ICFTU in Brussels. So the ORIT has been impacted from the grassroots,
if not the shopfloor. Or - if one prefers to concentrate on the institutionalised
expression of such - we could consider this as the horizontal impact of
the NGOs in the Americas. A major question facing both the ORIT and the
AFL-CIO (and the Canadian unions for that matter) must therefore be the
development of a healthy, open and democratic dialectic with civil society
more generally.
1. Author and address
Johns, Rebecca
University of South Florida
2. Subject or title
Seeing the Forest for the
Trees: Linking Labor and Environment Across Borders through the International
Federation of Building and Wood Workers
3. Abstract or description
I have a paper underway
which examines the work of the International Federation of Building and
Wood Workers to promote sustainable forestry around the world. I
am particularly interested in the efforts of the federation to bring together
labor and environmental concerns through some really interesting and innovative
programs. I am particularly interested in the way the federation links
workers regionally and across national boundaries to build the influence
it needs to get the job done. That cross-border regionalization/globalization
is the source of their success in promoting sustainable forestry as well
as protecting workers. I am also interested in exploring what the IFBWW
programs tell us about our concepts of justice....for so long I have focused
on the process of decision-making, and privileged notions of procedural
over distributive justice....but it seems that the outcomes are just as
important (more so?) than the process (I know there is literature about
‘substantive justice’ which I intend to explore), and in this case, both
outcomes and process are really interesting. My original interest in this
stuff was in contrasting the situation of forest workers in Europe to that
of forest workers in the Pacific Northwest of the U.S., and noting how
in Europe the cross-border organization and the linking of environment
and labor are both so strong that the workers have clearly benefitted....whereas
in the U.S. this is decidely not the case.
1. Author and address
Lambert, Rob
Regional Coordinator
Southern Initiative on Globalisation
and Trade Union Rights
University of Western Australia
Nedlands
Western Australia
Australia
2. Subject or title
The Movement's New Unity:
Reflections on a Conference of the Network of the Southern Initiative on
Globalisation and Trade Union Rights
3. Abstract or description
(Extract from article draft)
The radical nature of global
restructuring and the high mobility of capital requires a global unionism…
Moves are now in place to forge sector to sector links across specific
countries to trial run global unionism. Linkages through personnel exchanges
will transmit national experiences thereby creating a readiness to act
in the cause of geographically distant workers for these distant workers
will now be represented inside the collaborating union, working to raise
the awareness levels […] When Australian [dockworkers] leaders visited
the Durban docks in South Africa to personally thank workers for their
boycott actions, there was a high demand for T-shirts and other symbols.
These one-off meetings are valuable. Shared experience creates a real sense
of international solidarity… However, these positive acts do not create
a global unionism. For this to happen, structural links with a degree of
permanence have to be formed. Certain unions are already in process to
review the form of this change […] Unions that are presently leading global
campaigns against multinationals have found it essential to turn outwards
and form community alliances. The multinational mining giant that is attacking
worker rights in Australia in the name of individual freedom is the same
company that is cutting into Malagasy’s ancient forests to sand mine. The
interests of green groups and unions coalesce […] The conference will explore
the mechanics of these strategic shifts. The outcome will be the first
building blocks of a global social movement unionism not as an abstract
theoretical idea, but as a concrete organisational shift worked through
in all its detail.
1. Author and address
Carla Lipsig-Mumme
Director, Centre for Research
on Work and Society
York University
Toronto, Canada
carlalm@YorkU.CA
2. Subject or title
The Language of Organising:
Trade Union Strategy in
International Perspective
3. Abstract or description
Over the past decade, trade
unions in Australia, the U.K., the U.S. and to a lesser extent Canada,
have turned to organising new members as a principal strategy to redress
decline in union density and influence. The 'organising renaissance' has
developed its own international language which reveals the divergent uses
of organising, both among national labour movements and within them. In
addition, the international adoption and adaptation of the US 'Organising
Model' raises questions of international knowledge transfer and power relations
between labour movements. Three tensions define the organising renaissance:
the tension between transformative and instrumental organising; the tension
between recruitment of new members by trade unions, and representation
of workers by community organisations and workers' centres; and the tension
between internal strategies of organisational renewal and external strategies
of international action. This paper explores four aspects of the language
of organising: context, keywords, linkages between organising and community
unionism, and the relation between organising and international union action,
drawing on US, Australian, Canadian and British research.
1. Author and address
Luján, Bertha
Secretary
Frente Autentico del Trabajo
Godard No. 20
Col. Guadalupe Victoria
C.P. 07790
Mexico, DF
Mexico
Tel: +556-9314
Fax: +556-936
Email: fat@laneta.apc.org
2. Subject or title
Globalisation and Labour
Standards: The Case of the NAFTA
3. Abstract or description
(Extract from draft)
The process of globalisation
has been studied…almost exclusively, as an inevitable and unalterable phenomenon
of economic modernisation… But this process of globalisation also bears
with it aspects which are positive for workers and peoples… We would like
to emphasise three aspects, which are products of globalisation and favourable
to the peoples: a)…the increasing interrelationship between social, citizen
and political organisations… b) the reorganisation of labour movements
of the whole world in terms of their internal and external structures and
alliances… c) the shaping of a new agenda of struggle on behalf of workers
and peoples, expressed in different demands concerning the inclusion of
social agendas and clauses in international accords on trade and investment…
1. Author and address
Waterman, Peter
Jacob v.d. Doesstr 28
2518XN The Hague
Netherlands
Tel/Fax: +31-70-363-1539
Email: waterman@antenna.nl,
2. Subject or title
Some Propositions on the
Old Internationalism, the New Global Solidarity, a Future Global Civil
Society
3. Abstract or description
1. Internationalism in history:
it neither began nor does it end with labour and capital; 2. Whatever happened
to proletarian internationalism? 3. Whatever happened to socialist internationalism?
4. `Globalisation' is more than capitalism's latest ideology or highest
stage; 5. A complex globalisation provokes complex internationalisms; 6.
Responses to the Big G can be multiple, overlapping and interlocked; 7.
A complex capitalism needs (sorry!) a complex solidarity; 8. Will South
Africa move from a substitution to a rainbow internationalism?; 9. 'Poor
Mexico: so far from God, so close to the USA'? 10. Liverpool, UK: some
defeats are worth more than victories…; 11. Relating to other people is
not what we do but who we are; 12. The `future is not what it used to be'
(grafito, Buenos Aires) but… 'A map of the world than does not include
Utopia is not even worth glancing at' (Oscar Wilde); 13. Global civil society:
an unimaginable, or simply an unimagined, community? 14. International
democracy as process: civilising global society; 15. Women and internationalism:
from a room of one's own to the world as one's country…and back again;
16. On the Battle of Seattle: The whole world IS watching; 17. Democratising
labour's international affairs: civilising global society begins at home.
1. Author and address
Wills, Jane
Queen Mary and Westfield
College
University of London
2. Subject or title
Transnational Labour Organisation
in Europe:
Learning the Lessons from
European Works Councils
3. Abstract or description
1. Author and address
Wright, Melissa
University of Georgia
2. Subject or title
Organising in the Maquiladora,
Mexico
3. Abstract or description
Ciudad Juarez, Chihuahua,
is now infamous as a city rife with drug violence, the serial murders of
women, and the maquiladora factories. Over the last five years, the murder
rate in the city has skyrocketed to turn the city into Mexico’s murder
capital. While the maquiladora industry resists the notion that any connections
can be made between their industrial activity and the crime-rate, many
non-profit organizations are attempting to make such connections. In this
essay, I shall explore how one such group, El Ocho de Marzo, has deployed
the concept of community in order to force the multinational corporate
sector to address some of the social ills now plaguing the border region.
This group, organized by middle class women in Ciudad Juarez, worked with
international human rights groups as well as with domestic and foreign
journalists to create an international community that would raise the issue
of community accountability for the maquiladora industry. Through this
communal effort, the maquiladoras have been pressured to address some of
the violence that has arisen alongside their industrial endeavors. This
essay examines how the Ocho de Marzo’s strategy for manipulating the notions
of their community’s scale has successfully countered a multinational corporate
discourse of globalization as a delocalizing phenomenon.
|